Statia: ‘Who is going to pay for equality?’

10 min leestijd
Charles Woodley, President AF1

ORANJESTAD — Healthcare workers on St. Eustatius work 40 hours a week; their colleagues in the European Netherlands work 36. The Dutch House of Representatives does not want to provide extra money to close that gap. Even so, the union All for 1 (AF1) is standing firm: from 1 January 2027, the healthcare work week on Statia must be 36 hours, with no loss of pay.

‘AF1 will not move beyond January 1, 2027, on this matter,’ AF1 president Charles Woodley said in a statement on 30 September. For him, the question is no longer whether a shorter work week is desirable. ‘The question has become: Who is going to pay for equality?’

House votes down motion

On 29 September, the House of Representatives rejected a motion by 50PLUS MP Corrie van Brenk. She had asked the Dutch government for structural extra funding for a shorter healthcare work week on Bonaire, St. Eustatius and Saba. The motion received 35 votes in favour and 115 against: only PRO, SP, 50PLUS, Volt, PvdD, DENK and ChristenUnie supported it.

According to the motion, 36 hours is the norm in healthcare in the European Netherlands, and other public employers on the islands have already introduced that work week. Van Brenk described the labour market in the Caribbean Netherlands as vulnerable. The regular funding system for healthcare salaries, the OVA, would leave too little room to pay for the change.

Minister Sterk (Long-term Care, Youth and Sport) advised against the motion in the debate of 23 September. In her view, the work week is ‘first and foremost simply a responsibility of employers and employees’. She first wants to await talks with employers and further research into working hours and funding, but also into whether healthcare institutions can deploy enough staff.

Woodley considers that insufficient. ‘We do not need another generation of reports to tell us that 40 hours is not 36 hours,’ he said. ‘Where disparities exist, government should have the courage to address them.’

Money as the stumbling block

There appears to be little disagreement about the goal. Healthcare employers on the islands support a 36-hour week, but say they cannot afford it without extra government funding. Negotiations between employers and unions on a new collective labour agreement for BES healthcare have been on hold since early September, largely because of this issue.

AF1 believes The Hague must pick up the bill, which puts it directly at odds with the minister. ‘Our position is that equality cannot suddenly become a local responsibility simply because equality costs money,’ Woodley said. The union wants to prevent money from becoming the reason equal treatment is postponed once again.

‘Why must we continuously reinvent the wheel?’

Woodley frames the issue as a question of equality within the Kingdom. He points to the 1954 Charter for the Kingdom of the Netherlands, which describes a relationship on a basis of equality, and to UN Resolution 568 of 1952. ‘If St. Eustatius is part of the Netherlands, and our people are Dutch citizens, why must we continuously reinvent the wheel when something already exists and functions in the European Netherlands?’

AF1 acknowledges that the Charter mainly concerns the relationship between the countries of the Kingdom. Since 10-10-10, Statia has been a public entity within the Netherlands, which does not automatically mean identical rules in every area. According to the union, the principle nevertheless remains relevant to the political debate.

Woodley also points to how much time has already passed. ‘We entered this present constitutional structure on October 10, 2010. It is now 2026. Almost sixteen years have passed. How many more years do we need to identify disparities that everyone can already see?’

The union also points to a disparity on the island itself. Civil servants of the Public Entity St. Eustatius already work 36 hours. ‘If people recruited from the Netherlands can come here with better employment conditions than those available to people already working here, that creates another form of disparity,’ Woodley said.

Bonaire takes action too

Statia is not alone. On Bonaire, the union AFBW is running the same campaign, and healthcare workers on Saba also support the call. Since August, FNV, one of the largest trade unions in the Netherlands, has also backed the demand.

On 15 August, healthcare workers on Statia gathered at the AF1 office, among them staff from the Queen Beatrix Medical Center, the Auxiliary Home and Mental Health Caribbean. They stressed that they do not want to be treated differently from civil servants, who already work 36 hours.

On Bonaire, AFBW president Cherel Kwidama goes a step further. He told Caribisch Netwerk that staff recruited from the European Netherlands are placed higher on the salary scale than local colleagues in the same position, because their terms are negotiated on the basis of a 36-hour, or sometimes 32-hour, work week. Kwidama calls this discrimination and racism.

The union says it can substantiate this and challenges employers to prove otherwise. No response from employers to the accusation is known.

AFBW also considers the minister’s staffing argument insufficient. According to the union’s own research, about 10 percent more staff would be needed. Kwidama sees that as a problem to be solved, not a reason to reject the 36-hour week.

A shaky foundation

The fight over the work week is taking place in a healthcare system that lags behind on several fronts. That is the view of Dorette Courtar, a healthcare provider on St. Eustatius and committee member of the ZonMw programme Caribbean Health Research, in an interview with ZonMw in July this year.

According to Courtar, Saba, Statia and St. Maarten mainly lack expertise and cooperation. Money comes from the Netherlands, but the return is low. The basics are not equal either: a nurse on the islands, for example, is not required to be BIG-registered, the legal registration for healthcare professionals in the Netherlands, while in her view equal quality starts with equal basic requirements.

The fact that small numbers of people are involved does not make the problem any less serious, she says: in a Dutch village, such a situation would not be accepted. Sixteen years after 10-10-10, the system still does not work satisfactorily. Her goal is clear: it should not matter whether you see a doctor in the Netherlands or on the islands.

Courtar also points to a climate in which people sense which topics are better left alone. Those who criticise healthcare, she says, quickly become a target. Talking openly about healthcare must become normal, in her view.

Who will stay in healthcare?

AF1 links the demand to the island’s ability to attract and retain healthcare staff. ‘This is about fairness, but it is also about the future of healthcare,’ Woodley said. ‘If you want people to remain in healthcare, if you want to attract professionals, and if you want St. Eustatius to provide quality care, then the people providing that care must receive employment conditions that recognize their value.’

The union refers to a March 2026 advisory report on equivalent care in the Caribbean Netherlands. It recommended independent research into salaries and employment conditions, compared with the European Netherlands and with the region: Aruba, Curaçao and St. Maarten.

AF1 says it will keep up the pressure on the Dutch government and relevant institutions to reach a concrete solution before January. On Bonaire, AFBW is turning to the Legal Aid Desk and the National Ombudsman. So far, The Hague has made no commitment.

Deel dit artikel